
A neighbourhood that buys methanol is an 80% neighbourhood
A neighbourhood of eight homes near Breda reaches 90% self-sufficiency on paper for 954 euros per home per year if it buys methanol and does not count that fuel. It then burns about 2 tonnes of methanol a year. Count that fuel as an import and it reaches 78 to 79%, while an ordinary 80% neighbourhood without seasonal storage costs 384 euros. That is why this lab counts bought fuel as an import. A real 90% then costs 2,137 euros per home, with methanol the neighbourhood makes itself.
What counts as your own?
Image above: AI impression, not a construction drawing.
In Summer in a tank I calculated how eight all-electric homes near Breda store their summer electricity for the winter. The neighbourhood wants to generate 90% of its electricity itself. Methanol turned out to be the cheapest way. In summer you turn electricity, water and CO₂ into a liquid. In winter a fuel cell turns it back into electricity.
You can also buy methanol. Terraform Industries wants to make it from sunlight and air. Suppose the neighbourhood buys that methanol and puts it in its fuel cell in winter. Is that electricity then the neighbourhood's own?
I left that question open in the previous lab log. The answer decides what "90% self-sufficient" means.
If bought fuel does not count
Then 90% suddenly becomes cheap. The model no longer builds its own small methanol plant. It only installs a 5 kW fuel cell and buys the fuel. About 2 tonnes of methanol go through it every year, 2.5 to 2.7 cubic metres. That is almost three IBC containers.
All in, that costs 954 euros per home per year: panels, neighbourhood battery, fuel cell, fuel and the grid bill. With home-made methanol, 90% costs 2,137 euros. On paper, buying is more than twice as cheap.
Where that electricity comes from
A fuel cell turns about 35% of the energy in methanol into electricity. From 11 to 12 MWh of fuel a year, about 4 MWh of electricity comes back. That electricity comes from outside the neighbourhood, just like electricity from the grid. It just arrives by lorry.
Count those 4 MWh as an import and the neighbourhood is 78 to 79% self-sufficient, depending on the weather year.
A neighbourhood that reaches 80% with only panels and a neighbourhood battery, without seasonal storage, costs 384 euros per home per year. The neighbourhood that buys methanol pays 570 euros per home per year more. For that it gets slightly less of its own electricity, and the number 90.
My choice
I count bought fuel as an import. A kWh from a lorry comes from outside just as much as a kWh from the grid. Anyone who keeps fuel out of the sum can push the percentage up with a lorry. From now on this lab calculates it that way, in every sum with seasonal storage.
With that choice the model never buys methanol. Electricity from bought methanol costs about 78 cents per kWh. Electricity from the grid costs about 30 cents on average. If both count equally, the grid wins. Buying only becomes interesting below about 580 euros per tonne. That is roughly the price of methanol made from natural gas, which is outside this question.
A real 90% then costs 2,137 euros per home per year, with methanol the neighbourhood makes from its own summer electricity.
What the sum says
- If bought methanol does not count, 90% self-sufficiency costs 954 euros per home per year.
- Counted honestly, that neighbourhood reaches 78 to 79%.
- An ordinary 80% neighbourhood without seasonal storage costs 384 euros.
- That is why this lab counts bought fuel as an import. The model then never buys methanol.
- A real 90% costs 2,137 euros per home, with home-made methanol.
What this rests on
The weakest points, for anyone who wants to attack this:
- The price of green methanol. I use 1,500 euros per tonne. At 1,000 euros the buying neighbourhood costs 801 euros per home and, counted honestly, reaches 70 to 76%. At 2,000 euros it costs 1,076 euros and reaches about 80%. What a small buyer actually pays is unknown.
- No tank. The model lets the supplier deliver exactly on time. In reality a tank for a year's supply comes on top. That only makes buying more expensive.
- The fuel cell. The smallest available, 5 kW, with 35% efficiency. The heat it gives off is not counted.
- The same neighbourhood as in the previous lab log. 10 kWp per home, the weather years 2018, 2021 and 2022, feed-in at the market price. The model knows the weather in advance.
Check it. If you know what a neighbourhood of eight homes pays for green methanol, I will recalculate it.